© 2026 The Couch Critic
Status
Released
Release
2012
Runtime
1h 19m
"Once, Twice, Three Times an Amy."
In 1992, a suburban New York teenager named Amy Fisher captured the national media's attention when she shot her lover's wife in the face. This sordid tale of underage sex, aggravated assault, and Joey Buttafuoco managed to spawn not one, not two, but three separate made-for-TV movies. Drew Barrymore, Alyssa Milano and Noëlle Parker all took stabs at portraying the disturbed young lady, yet a true on-screen depiction of Amy Fisher has never emerged - until now. In this Rashomon of found footage film, director Dan Kapelovitz mind-melds the multiple melodramas into one ultimate metadrama mashup.
12 Cast Members
Noelle Parker
Amy Fisher (archive footage from "Amy Fisher: My Story")
Drew Barrymore
Amy Fisher (archive footage from "The Amy Fisher Story")
Alyssa Milano
Amy Fisher (archive footage from "Casualties of Love")
Ed Marinaro
Joey Buttafuoco (archive footage from "Amy Fisher: My Story")
Tony Denison
Joey Buttafuoco (archive footage from "The Amy Fisher Story")
Jack Scalia
Joey Buttafuoco (archive footage from "Casualties of Love")
Kathleen Laskey
Mary Jo Buttafuoco (archive footage from "Amy Fisher: My Story")
Laurie Paton
Mary Jo Buttafuoco (archive footage from "The Amy Fisher Story")
Phyllis Lyons
Mary Jo Buttafuoco (archive footage from "Casualties of Love")
Boyd Kestner
Paul Makely (archive footage from "Amy Fisher: My Story")
Philip Maurice Hayes
Paul Makely (archive footage from "The Amy Fisher Story")
Michael Bowen
Paul Makely (archive footage from "Casualties of Love")
