© 2026 The Couch Critic
Recently released from her vows as a nun, Christine Bennett is discovering "life on the outside." After a visit to her mentally-handicapped cousin Gene, Christine becomes embroiled in the investigation of the murder mystery surrounding James and Edward Talley, twin savant brothers accused of killing their mother on Good Friday.
24 Cast Members
Megan Ward
Christine Bennett
Morgan Weisser
Det. Jack Brooks
Rutanya Alda
Virginia McAlpin
David Proval
James Talley /Edward Talley - Age 55
Rafael Feldman
James Talley (Age 24)
Daryl Sabara
James Talley (Age 10)
Yan Feldman
Edward Talley (Age 24)
Evan Sabara
Edward Tally (Age 10)
Laura Kirk
Alberta Talley
Rodger Bumpass
Patrick Talley Jr.
Lawrence Pressman
Dr. G.K. Sanderson
Patty Duke
Mother Joseph
Gina Gallego
Maria Santos Padilla
Matt Lutz
Gene Wirth
Allyson Rees-Stevens
Melanie Gross
Bob Delegall
Det. Abe Lorenz
Janet Rotblatt
Selma Franklin
Don Simmons
Patrick's Lawyer
Rod McCary
Dan Tuxford
Mary Margaret Robinson
Mayor Joan Primrose
