© 2026 The Couch Critic
A priest returns to his old Catholic high school to replace a priest who has gone missing, only to begin to suspect that the missing priest may have been murdered by someone at the school to hide a darker secret.
22 Cast Members
Isaiah Washington
Father Andre James
Robert Loggia
Father William Jennings
Jordan Garrett
Parker Remy
Andrew Lawrence
Jason Boyd
Bob Gunton
Father Thomas Peters
John Billingsley
Father Alfred McKavee
John Bain
Eddie
Charlie Stewart
Fritz
Dean Collins
Travis
Creagen Dow
Patrick
Kirk B.R. Woller
Detective Crowe
Traber Burns
Bishop Anderson
Anne Marie Howard
News Reporter
Lance Guest
Mark Roberts
Daniel Samonas
Stephen
Faline England
Jennifer
Spencer Daniels
Alex
Mary Thornton
Doctor
Rebecca Wackler
Secretary
Stephen A. Marinaccio II
Priest in Lake
