© 2026 The Couch Critic
Status
Released
Release
2018
Runtime
48m
Available options inUS
In When You Wish Upon a Pickle, a mysterious wish machine appears on Sesame Street and the magical pickle inside starts granting wishes. Before long, the gang learns they need to be careful what they wish for – especially when they find out he’ll only grant one wish per customer!
39 Cast Members
Christopher Knowings
Chris
Suki Lopez
Nina
Ryan Dillon
Elmo
Peter Linz
Ernie / Herry Monster
Eric Jacobson
Bert / Grover / Oscar / Guy Smiley
David Rudman
Cookie Monster
Leslie Carrara-Rudolph
Abby Cadabby
Stephanie D'Abruzzo
Gale Warning
Matt Vogel
Wish Pickle / Mr. Johnson / Big Bird / The Count
Amanda Seyfried
Natalie Neptune
Blake Lively
Delivery Person
Ilana Glazer
Ms. Noodle
Jennifer Barnhart
Zoe / Gladys the Cow
Pam Arciero
Grundgetta / Shoes / Jacket
Justiin A. Davis
Self
Deborah Grausman
Smartie
Tyler Bunch
Frankie Cordero
John E. Kennedy
Carmen Osbahr