© 2026 The Couch Critic
Available options inUS
At the height of her career, investigative journalist Hannah Dunbar finds herself wondering what would have been had she stayed with the love of her life, Ben, 10 years before. When Santa Claus hears her “what ifs?” as a Christmas wish, he transports Hannah to a version of her life where she and Ben started a family.
19 Cast Members
Lacey Chabert
Hannah Dunbar
Tyron Leitso
Ben Matthews
Matthew Kevin Anderson
Grant Walker
Brittney Wilson
Carrie Garrett
Jill Morrison
Tammy Frink
Keith MacKechnie
Santa Clause
James Kirk
Carl Oxley
Milli Wilkinson
Caitlin
Audrey Smallman
Hallie
Michael St. John Smith
Harold Wainright
Michael Meneer
Anchor Man
Danny Mac
Rob Frink
Laura Adkin
Mary Beth Harvey
Lee Tichon
Security Guard
Kat Karpoff
Sheila
Chris Nowland
Stuart
Michael Bean
Waiter
Aaron Hutchinson
Suburban Man
Allyson Grant
Stroller Mom
