© 2026 The Couch Critic
Available options inUS
"This is the true story of her family's search for justice."
On May 30, 2005, on a high school graduation trip to Aruba, she disappeared without a trace.
19 Cast Members
Amy Gumenick
Natalee Holloway
Tracy Pollan
Beth Holloway-Twitty
Grant Show
Jug Twitty
Catherine Dent
Carol
Natasha Loring
Hayley
Jacques Strydom
Joran Van Der Sloot
Kim Senogles
Justine
Erin Cloytier
Darla
Clayton Evertson
Deepak Kalpoe
Hein De Vries
Satish Kalpoe
Julie Summers
Barbara Waxman
Cokey Falkow
Patrick van Eem
Leigh Bremridge
Diana Peterson
Susan Danford
Maggie
Sean Cameron Michael
Paul van der Sloot
Sean Higgs
Detective Frank Sneider
André Jacobs
Detective Roemer
Bjorn Steinbach
Brent
Wayne Harrison
Dave Holloway
