© 2026 The Couch Critic
We’ve recently uncovered some lost footage. Take a look…
26 Cast Members
Tamara Lynn Chambers
Dolores
Doug Walker
Nostalgia Critic
Malcolm Ray
Contestant #1
Brett Bonynge
Contestant #2
Robbie Allen
Bob
Alyssa Jackson
Barbara
Paul Rohan
Ben
Jimmy Melf
Reilly
Harry Locke IV
Julio
Jim Jarosz
Rolly the Fox/Practitioner
Heather Reusz
Atlantis Somerset
Nick La Banca
Nautical Nineties Narrator
Justin Hoffman
"Spin My Helm" Singer
McKane Searle
"Spin My Helm" Bassist
James Banasiak
"Spin My Helm" Drummer
Alexis Banasiak
Waving Woman 1
Mooog
Waving Woman 2
Rob Scallon
Waving Man
Catheryn Kuhar
Sailor Girl
Danny Grenchik
"Shark Weak" Singer
