© 2026 The Couch Critic
Available options inUS
"Nothing is as it seems."
College student Deena visits her hometown and is roped into a babysitting gig. Meanwhile, the local sheriff, after receiving a piece of evidence in the mail, falls into an increasingly desperate scavenger hunt involving a series of murders.
19 Cast Members
Jessica Clement
Deena
Ryan Robbins
Sheriff Rodney Arnold
Summer H. Howell
Emily Golding
Keegan Connor Tracy
Elizabeth Talbot
Matty Finochio
Officer Butch Cassidy
Max Christensen
Max Arnold
Ben Cockell
Chad
David Feehan
The Reaper
Bryn Samuel
Willis Hanover
Savannah Miller
Haddie
Susan Serrao
Sheila
Huxley Fisher
Mark
Isla Spencer
Marina
Sofie Kane
Dottie
Deborah Ferguson
Mrs. Dunham
Blair Young
Dr. Hall
Jocelyn Chugg
Abby
Lonni Olson
Walt
Drake Seipert
Connor Davis
