© 2026 The Couch Critic
"Someone’s idea of a high school prank is about to turn very deadly!"
When a New England high schooler is mysteriously murdered, the town blames Sarah, the new girl who recently moved into a purportedly haunted house and who they believe to be the reincarnation of a witch who was burned at the stake 300 years ago.
17 Cast Members
Sarah Chalke
Sarah Zoltanne
Soleil Moon Frye
Kyra Thompson
Ben Foster
Charlie
Christian Campbell
Eric Garrett
Maggie Lawson
Debbie Murdock
Chad Cox
Kevin Lane
Markie Post
Rosemary Zoltanne
Tom Dugan
Ted Rankin
Julie Patzwald
Misty
Laura Mennell
Sarah Lancaster
Gillian Barber
Eric's Mother
Kathleen Duborg
Miss Elting
Carly Pope
Cheerleader
Aaron Smolinski
Teammate
BJ Harrison
Librarian
Tom Heaton
Homeless Man
Ron Sauvé
Gas Station Attendant
