© 2026 The Couch Critic
Available options inUS
Hallmark Hall of Fame presents the story of a mysterious woman claiming to be the deceased daughter of a rich man tries to solve the problems of his untrusting son and supposedly physically and mentally handicaped daughter. But one question stands in her way: is she really Caroline?
26 Cast Members
Stephanie Zimbalist
Caroline
Pamela Reed
Grace Carmichael
George Grizzard
Paul Carmichael
Patricia Neal
Miss Trollope
Dorothy McGuire
Flora Atkins
Shawn Phelan
Winston Carmichael
Jenny Jacobs
Heidi Carmichael
Libby Whittemore
Bunny
John Evans
Winston as Adult
Barbara Britton
Hilary
John Bennes
Simmons
Judith Sullivan
Agnes
Mary Nell Santacroce
Aunt Helen
Dan Albright
Mr. Phillips
Warde Q. Butler
Randolph
Marc Gowan
Harvey
Alice Heffernan-Sneed
Luellen
Randi Layne
Charlotte
Jeff Young Lewis
Freddie
Audray McCroskey
Waitress
